When I started teaching in 2007, I called myself a piano teacher in training, charged Β£10 a lesson and let every cancellation go without a second thought. Nobody told me piano teaching wasn't a real job. I just ran my studio as if it wasn't, and it took me years to see it.
In this episode:
The expectations I grew up with, and why piano teaching never felt like a proper job
How music gets treated as an extra, from schools to the GCSE years
My rates and policies from my side-job years to now
Why "I'm lucky it's not my main income" affects every music teacher
What my CertPTC qualification did and didn't change
Real stories of teachers making a living from private teaching
The objections that keep teachers undervaluing their work, with honest reframes
Links mentioned:
ISM Music Teachers' Fees Survey Results 2026
Episode 6: Stop Chasing Payments: My Monthly Billing System
Episode 8: I Don't Work Late and I Don't Work Weekends: Here's How
Episode 10: You Are a Professional Music Teacher
Episode 11, What Makes a Good Music Teacher
Episode 12: You're Not an Average Teacher, So Stop Charging an Average Rate
Know a teacher who'd love to make teaching their living? Please share this episode with them. And if you've enjoyed it, a rating or review helps other teachers find the show.
-
Part 1: Where the belief comes from
Β£10 on Gumtree
When I first started teaching, back in 2007, I put an advert on Gumtree looking for five adult piano students. I described myself as a piano teacher in training, because somehow that made it feel more acceptable to ask for money. I charged Β£10 for a 30-minute lesson. I know, I know, it's ridiculously low, even for 2007. People paid me on the day, not in advance, and I'd write out a little receipt. If somebody cancelled, even at the last minute, they just didn't pay, and I didn't mind at all, because this wasn't my real job. My real job was in pharmaceutical market research.
I had a studio policy, based on the one my own piano teacher had given me, but I never used it with those first students. So there was no notice period, and nothing to refund, because nothing was ever paid in advance. I really didn't mind at all. I was so new to it, and it wasn't my main source of income.
The thing is, nobody ever told me piano teaching wasn't a real job. I just ran it as if it wasn't. And it took me so many years to see that.
I'm Victoria. I started teaching piano part-time 18 years ago, alongside a career in pharmaceutical market research, and I made pretty much every mistake you can make when it comes to running a teaching business. But today I run a thriving studio from my home on the south coast of England, with students I love and a waiting list I'm proud of. I started this podcast because I want that for you too.
If you've ever said yes to a reschedule you really didn't want to do, felt your heart sink when your phone buzzed with another last minute cancellation, or found yourself putting off increasing your fees for another year because the timing never feels quite right, this is the podcast for you. I've been there and come out the other side with a teaching business that lights me up every single day, and I'm here to help you do the same.
What this episode covers
Welcome to another episode of The Victoria Clark Show for Music Teachers. Today's topic is all about where the belief that music teaching isn't a real job comes from, and what it costs us as music teachers. We'll look at the messages we absorb growing up, the "I'm lucky it's not my main income" idea we see all too often online, why a qualification won't fix it on its own, and why earning a living from teaching is absolutely possible.
This topic really matters for all of us, this idea that music teaching isn't a "real job" (in inverted commas). It has a personal cost. We charge low rates. We have studio policies we politely ignore, because that's easier than reinforcing a policy we don't quite believe we deserve. We ignore notice periods, because we don't believe we deserve them. We reschedule lessons at the expense of our own time. And all that income and time just leaks away without us noticing.
There are lots of problems with all of this, and I say that from a place of having been there myself. Now I'm on the other side of it, respecting my profession as a music teacher and everything that goes into it. It feels unbearable when I read about music teachers charging so little, and not believing they deserve to charge any more, or to stand up for their notice periods or protect their time.
Families mirror how we value ourselves
One of the problems is that our student families, our piano parents (or the parents of whatever instrument you teach), mirror how we value ourselves. When we treat our own teaching as a side activity, our families do the same. And it has a collective cost.
The way each of us runs our studio (whether you call it a studio or not; it took me a long time to call mine a studio, even though it's literally the lounge in my house). It's nothing fancier than that. Yes, I've made it nice and tidy, and when you go in, it's all music and games and the piano and a place to sit, a nice place to learn. It's still just the lounge of my family home, but it is my music studio.
Anyway, the way each of us runs our studio shapes the expectations families bring to every music teacher they meet. Say a student family started lessons with someone who really doesn't see themselves as a professional, who describes themselves (to use the piano example) as, "Oh, I teach piano lessons on the side," or "I teach piano lessons in my spare time," rather than "I am a piano teacher." It's a subtle difference, but a huge one in terms of the mindset you hold, and what you put across to new students and families.
And one of the saddest things about this whole idea that it isn't really a real job is that the teachers who pay the price most are the ones who really want, or need, to make teaching their living.
When I think back to how I ran my early years of teaching, with people paying on the day, no notice period and no cancellation policy, I just want to shake myself by the shoulders and say, "Stop giving your income away. Stop giving your time away. What you're doing has value. You're teaching someone to play the piano. Yes, you love it, and yes, it feels easy, but that doesn't mean it isn't worth the money you're charging. In fact, it's worth more than you're charging." It's a real service you're providing, and even though it seems easy to you, it's really valuable knowledge, instruction and interaction that not everyone can provide.
Traditional expectations
This is just me sharing my own experiences. I realise everyone will have had their own experiences and been exposed to different ideas, and what I'm about to cover in this episode may not resonate with you, and that's fine. But I want to share my experience in case it does resonate with you, if you've had similar experiences but never questioned them.
I have very traditional parents. Their expectation for me and my sister was that we'd work hard at school, get good grades and get into a good university, so we could get a good degree and a well-paid job in a respectable profession. As a parent myself, I can totally understand that approach. They wanted security for us both: to be able to support ourselves, earn enough to get a mortgage, get on the property ladder and live a secure life. It makes perfect sense, and that's exactly why the message is so easy to absorb and so hard to question.
For me personally, I never even asked about becoming a piano teacher. In truth, maybe it did occur to me, but I never entertained it as a reality, because I knew my path was set out before me. I was very fortunate that I found academia quite easy. Well, it got harder and harder as you went up the chain, but I didn't struggle at school. I was socially very awkward, don't get me wrong, but the things that mattered for getting good grades were all fine, and I had my piano lessons and excelled at those, and life was great.
Why I started teaching on the side
That's why it took me by surprise when I decided to start teaching piano part-time alongside my then main career in pharmaceutical market research. When I reflect on it, I don't know where the idea came from, because while I was studying for my biology degree, I certainly wasn't thinking, "As soon as I finish this degree, I'm going to start a part-time piano teaching business alongside a brand new career." I didn't think that at all.
Thinking back, I wonder if it was because I was taking my first big step along a corporate path, which maybe felt like, "Once you're on this path, you don't deviate." So I wonder if, without realising, I thought, "If I start some piano teaching now, I'll get to experience it, because I know I'm going to love it more than this unknown thing." I've got a number of theories, but that's the one that fits best at the moment with how I was probably thinking back then. I was going into something new that I didn't really understand, because up until then we've all only ever experienced school and exams, then college and university, and the real world of work is nothing like school life.
So absolutely, I saw part-time piano teaching as not really a real job. It was something I wanted to try as a treat for me, something I could enjoy on the side.
I'd love to hear from you. Think about the messages you grew up with about what counts as a proper job. Like I said, not everyone will have had the same experience as me. But reflecting on everything I've experienced, the message about what makes a proper job has influenced me enormously, in my life and my choices. I think it's very useful to reflect on where those ideas came from, and how ingrained they are in you, because they form part of your mindset and your approach to music teaching.
Music is always the first to go
We see this in the news all the time, don't we? Whenever schools are struggling with funding, what's the first thing to go? The arts. They cut music, art and drama, and academic subjects come first. Music is treated as an extra, something to fit in around everything else.
This comes up every exam season, with GCSE students. It's been the topic of much debate in many of the groups I read: when students are studying for their GCSEs, do you allow them to pause lessons so they can spend the time revising, or do you stick to your policies and make sure they keep coming to lessons, or at least keep paying for them? I know which side I fall on, but I'm not saying that's how everyone should think, of course. It's only my personal opinion, based on my own experiences.
When I was studying for my GCSEs and A levels, I didn't miss a single piano lesson. Part of that was because I enjoyed it so much, but it was also a welcome relief from the obligation to spend every last minute revising and studying, because that's what I did. I definitely wasn't the sort of person who could wing it, or pull an all-nighter; I need my sleep. So every single day, on study leave, I'd get up early, eat breakfast fairly quickly and sit down in the same place. I remember studying in the lounge, because there was more room than in my hot, stuffy bedroom. I'd have all my coloured pens out beside me, my textbooks, the curriculum and everything, and I'd approach it in a very methodical way.
So nothing changed about my schedule. I kept going to my piano lessons and kept practising, maybe a bit less than usual, which was fine. But it never even crossed my mind to think, "Oh, I can't go to my piano lesson. I've got to stop piano lessons, because this is too much." Things may have changed in the last 30 years or so, which is fair enough, but I still feel, when this topic comes up, that it's valuable for the student to continue.
How I handle exam pressure in my studio
In my studio, no one has ever asked to stop lessons for exams. But it's been raised: "They're preparing for their next exams, or mocks, or whatever's coming up, so there'll be a bit less practice than you're used to." That would come from the parents, and that's absolutely fine.
In fact, that's how I approach it. I've learned to keep track of what age my students are, what year group they're in, and what they're likely to be studying for. So often I'll proactively ask, "Have you got some busy times coming up at school? If so, don't worry at all about fitting in enough practice. If you're happy to practise, do. If it's just too much stress, don't worry. We can adapt the lessons during this time, so you still get the benefit of your lessons without any extra stress, and we can keep it all going." That has worked for all my students who've been in that position, and the parents are happy with it.
I will say that in the past I've lost one or two teenage students because school got busier. But often it was because piano wasn't their main joy any more, or practice had become a struggle, and everything was feeling a bit overwhelming, so it was the right thing for them to stop. We know how overscheduled kids are these days, and I certainly wouldn't want piano lessons to be one more block on a tall Jenga stack that's going to come tumbling down. That's not what we want at all. Not every student stopping is about bias between academic subjects and music. It's about the individual as well.
Music is worth learning for its own sake
How often have you heard people justify music lessons by saying music helps with maths, or with complex thinking, or with exam results? I've done it myself. But when we say that kind of thing, we're agreeing that academic subjects are the measure, the most important thing.
Music is worth learning for its own sake. There are so many things music provides that academia rarely does. I say "rarely" because some people will get that joy, that emotional connection and that form of expression from academic subjects. I'd say it's far less common than with music, but it's not that it doesn't exist at all. Music offers so much that benefits us: our wellbeing, our state of mind, our ability to manage daily life and live fulfilling lives. There's so much more to it than "it helps with maths".
And I say that having described it that way myself. If I think about my website at the moment, I'm pretty sure there's a comment on my home page about the cognitive improvements music provides, because we want to bridge the gap between what everybody thinks (that academia is the most valuable thing, and music comes second) and the reality, that music is valuable in its own right.
Part 2: My own path from side job to real job
The thing I looked forward to
When I think back to my part-time piano teaching life, when it was very much my side job alongside my career, I loved it from the word go. I loved it so much that, in a way, it ruined my career job for me, because I realised what it was like to absolutely love the thing you do for work.
That's not to say I didn't get anything from being a pharmaceutical market researcher, because I did, and I enjoyed lots of aspects of it. There were lots of elements I didn't enjoy, but that's not specific to that industry. The corporate world just wasn't for me, and it took me a very long time to realise that. But the part-time teaching alongside it was the thing I looked forward to.
When we lived in Putney, I was commuting, and it still took me an hour to get into work. Then we moved out to Woking, and believe it or not, that took about the same time. I'd do my full day at work, with all the busyness and stress of trying to get everything done, to-do lists hardly touched and all the rest of it. I'd come home feeling completely worn out, and then start getting ready for the one or two piano students coming to see me that evening.
I kid you not, my whole being would light up. I'd be completely spent and exhausted by the time I got off the train, and then when I was teaching, all of that went away. I got to forget about the stresses of the workday, be in the moment and love what I was doing, seeing the light bulb moments come on for my students when they worked something out, played it, and realised how beautiful a new phrase sounded, or whatever we were doing. Afterwards I'd be buzzing.
So it was very clear to me right from the beginning that I absolutely loved this, but I really did just see it as my side job. I never considered it would become my full-time job. I think I romanticised about it: "Oh, wouldn't it be wonderful if I could just do this full-time?" But then, "No, of course you can't, because you'll never earn enough money to get a good mortgage," and all the rest of those worries. It was a daydream I never thought would become reality. So I pushed it to one side: "Nope, you've got to do the hard thing. You've got to stick with the 'real job'," in inverted commas.
Feeling like I was cheating
That starting rate of Β£10 per 30-minute lesson meant charging Β£20 an hour, only paid on the day, with no notice period, and a policy I just never used. I had the studio policy from my piano teacher, but I read it and thought, "I'm never going to say this to anyone. I'm going to hide it in a drawer." And all the income lost every time someone cancelled, I just didn't register as income lost. I thought, "Well, they haven't had their lesson, so they haven't spent any money. And my time is what it is."
When we moved to Woking, I raised my rate to Β£15 per 30-minute lesson. That was really because we'd moved, so I had new students, and I didn't have to face increasing my rates with existing students. As we all know, that's quite a terrifying thing the first time you do it, but well worth it. I recognised that I'd gained some experience from that first time teaching in Putney, so it was worth raising my rate a little. It was still below average, but I didn't really realise; I just thought, "That feels safe enough."
In fact, I remember feeling like I was cheating when I quoted my new rate to some of the students I took on. I don't know if that makes sense. It felt as though you could just pluck a figure out of the air and say, "Lessons cost this much," and it felt a bit wrong. When I look back, it was just because I didn't believe my time was worth anything, and because I didn't see piano teaching as a job for the money. It wasn't about the money. That's how it felt.
That's a lovely reason to start teaching, but the problem is that the same belief makes charging properly feel wrong. Even once teaching is paying your bills, whether you're full-time or not, it can feel really wrong when you went into it thinking, "It's not about the money; it's because I love music and want to share it with everyone." That's how we all feel, right? But it runs into the problem of: "Well, yes, but if you charge properly, you're being too business-like. You've lost the love of music, and you're just trying to make money out of it." No, it's not that at all. It's all about your mindset. Loving what you do is exactly why it's worth charging properly for it, so you can keep doing it for decades without burning out.
Going full-time in 2019
In 2019, as many of you already know, I switched to full-time piano teaching. I'd just lost my mum, and realised life was too short to do a job you don't love. And I had this amazing opportunity staring me in the face: "You absolutely love piano teaching. Go and do that. Do the thing that makes you happy, and makes other people happy as well. But do the thing that makes you happy."
I remember talking it through with my husband, to make sure it was going to be financially viable. He's great; he's very good with money. He made sure we had all our numbers right and knew how much I needed to bring in each month, which was such a small amount it was amazing. I still don't quite understand how he managed it, but we made it work. When it came to telling my dad, I just said, "This is what I need to do," and he was supportive, as he always has been. So I didn't need anyone's permission, but I did need to believe in it myself.
So I went for it, full speed. I thought, "Right, I'm going to do this. I'm going to teach full-time. It's going to be amazing, and it's going to be hard work." I have to admit, I was probably on high alert for quite a while. I spent every waking moment thinking of ways to make myself visible online and in the community. I had flyers made, and I remember walking for hours, posting them through people's letterboxes: "I'm a local piano teacher, just around the corner from you." I had an introductory offer that first Christmas, of four lessons for Β£60, I think, which related back to my old rate of Β£15 per 30-minute lesson. But I'd increased my rate to Β£18, based on the ISM teacher fees survey. I got serious about my studio policy at the same time.
The old insecurities came with me
But the thing is, all my old insecurities came with me. Even though I knew this was a proactive decision I'd made, and I was excited about it ("Yes, this is my chance to do the thing I've loved for years and years"), I billed termly. Nothing wrong with that; families paid up front, which was good. But whenever they missed a lesson, for any reason, I automatically carried it over to the next term, because I was too chicken to stand up for my own policy.
I had the policy, and I remember that as each new person signed up to be my student, they'd get a one-sided piece of paper with all the policy details on it, clearly saying that lessons would not be rescheduled. Or, I think in my first version, that missed lessons could be rescheduled at the teacher's discretion, because I wanted to keep control over that, and if I couldn't reschedule them, that was that; they wouldn't get a refund. And I remember thinking, "Well, they've read it once, so they'll stick to it." How naive I was.
That's not how humans work. You read terms and conditions, or maybe skim them, and think, "Okay, yep, that looks fairly standard." Then when it comes to it, lots of people forget the details, or try to push the boundaries, because that's how they operate. It's not that they don't respect them; they just want to see if there's some wiggle room here and there.
For someone with a lot of imposter syndrome at the time, and fairly low self-confidence, it was like knocking over a feather. I had no stability or robustness when it came to standing up for my studio policies, because I just didn't want the confrontation or the awkwardness. And the old beliefs ("I do this because I love it; I don't really need the money") didn't let me go, even though we did need the money at that time, because this was part of the plan.
So, even in 2019, the result of the way I ran my studio was that I was still leaking income all over the place. Missed lessons were just shuffled forward, and rescheduled lessons weren't charged for, so I was giving away time and income, while still charging a fairly low rate: Β£18 for a 30-minute lesson, or Β£36 an hour.
Where I am now
Fast forward to now: my monthly rate is Β£77, which works out at Β£24.32 for a half-hour lesson, which is Β£48.64 per hour. If you want more information on how to make that kind of change, I'm going to link two episodes in the show notes. One is Episode 6, all about monthly billing. If you've never considered it, I recommend you listen to it, because it demystifies the whole process. And don't worry: if you don't teach all year round (I don't), you can still do monthly billing, and that's why it's so beneficial. I'll also link Episode 12, "You're Not An Average Teacher, So Stop Charging An Average Rate". I know it's got a bit of a bossy title, but it's a very useful one as well.
The point I want to make here is that your identity comes first, and the practical changes follow once you believe the work is worth protecting.
"I'm a piano teacher"
So I had this shift from "Oh, I teach piano lessons after work," or "I teach piano lessons on the side," whenever anyone asked or it came up in conversation. Then, when teaching became my full-time job (and it wasn't full-time at first, of course, because you have to build your reputation and visibility and attract students), I immediately switched to saying, "I'm a piano teacher."
It was an immediate switch, but I remember a change in how I said it. At first I'd look down a bit and say, "Oh, I'm a piano teacher," bashfully, as if to say, "Well, I'm just a piano teacher." I didn't say "just", but that's how it came across. Then, once the mindset shift had fully happened, I remember meeting people at friends' birthday parties (not that we go to loads of parties), and when they asked, "Oh, what do you do?", I'd say, "I'm a piano teacher," with a big smile on my face, because I was so proud of what I was and what I was doing. It's one of the few occupations where you can say it and people know, more or less, exactly what you do. Although we still have to contend with the whole "piano teachers are old grannies supplementing their pension" thing, but that's another story.
The change that made the biggest difference
If I think back to all the changes I've made over my time as a piano teacher, part-time or full-time, the one that has made the biggest difference to my income is, hands down, switching to monthly billing. Not just because it gave me a regular income without the peaks and troughs of termly billing, but because it had the knock-on effect of letting me uphold my studio policies in a much more genuine way, one that didn't make me feel like an imposter saying, "Well, this is my policy, and this is what you have to obey."
It was more, "This is what I believe in. This is what I'm worth. I believe in my worth, so this is what I charge, and these are my policies." It gave me the confidence and strength to know and believe in myself enough to feel I provided enough value to withstand losing any students who disagreed with my policies. Because, of course, students who disagree with your policies aren't your ideal students, so you let them go and make space for your ideal students to come in.
So switching to monthly billing has had the most profound impact on my income, my time and my sense of self. It's definitely one I'd recommend if you've ever thought about it, or even if you never have. If you've thought, "Well, we've always done termly billing, it's always been fine, and we don't know any different," I'd encourage you to learn a little about it. Listen to Episode 6 on monthly billing. It will give you a new perspective on how you could be doing your invoicing.
Part 3: "I'm lucky it's not my main income"
The comment no one calls out
I'd like to address something we've probably all seen online in teacher groups, which no one really calls out for what it is, so that's what I'm going to do now. It might be controversial, but I think it's an important point to make.
I'm always talking about these really big piano teacher groups because that's where I hang out. I do have a life outside of this, I must say! But it's who I am. It usually comes up in conversation threads about notice periods, missed lesson fees or rescheduling, and it's this, or a variation of it: "I'm fortunate that I don't rely on piano teaching as my main source of income," or "Piano teaching isn't my main income."
The key point is that these comments present it as accepted that you could never earn enough as a piano teacher to support yourself, which just isn't true. I'm a case in point: I support myself and my family through piano teaching, and that's it.
The teachers making these comments aren't doing anything wrong, and often they're trying to be kind. So many teachers believe they're being selfless by charging less, refunding lessons and being endlessly flexible. But without realising it, they're reinforcing the idea that music teaching is something you can pick up and put down as you please. For many of us, it's our livelihood, and it deserves to be paid for and respected properly. So there's a bit of a clash, where these teachers are happily sharing their thoughts, but the underlying message is, "Well, you can't really make a living from teaching piano on its own anyway, can you?"
The grandparent who asked about my real job
In fact, I remember laughing out loud once. I had finally made the mindset switch to "I'm a piano teacher, and I'm proud of it." It was one of the first times a particular student's grandparent had brought them to their lesson. She was perfectly nice, the lesson went really well, and it was all great. Then at the end she said to me, "So what do you do for a real job?"
I couldn't help but laugh. I smiled at her and said, "This is my real job." And it wasn't awkward. She may have felt awkward for asking, but I just found it funny that it was so inconceivable to her. I was in my late 30s then (I'm now in my forties), and it was perfectly fine to be a full-time piano teacher supporting my family and earning a respectable living. It sticks in my mind because it made me laugh so much.
Your choices ripple out
The teachers who say they're (in inverted commas) "lucky it's not my main income" are more than likely unaware of the impact their comments have on teachers who rely on teaching as their main career. That side of it rarely gets acknowledged, which is why it's worth talking about. In fact, it's probably something I'll start a conversation about, because more of us need to be aware that you're not doing anyone a favour by undercharging. You're certainly not doing the teaching community a favour, and you're not doing your students a favour either, because what happens? You end up as a burnt-out teacher who has to get a different job to supplement their income, and so on.
So two messages come through in all of this. Your choices as a music teacher ripple out further than you think. And you deserve to be paid properly too, even if you don't need the money.
I was this teacher once, when I was teaching part-time. I felt embarrassed asking for money. I accepted the money from each student very awkwardly as they arrived for their lessons. I did it for the love of teaching, because it really lit me up, and being paid for it was a nice little extra; it wasn't about the money. I was that teacher. So the points I'm making come from lived experience and understanding. I'm not being judgemental, I promise.
But there are so many teachers in these groups doing a main job plus their teaching, who'd absolutely love to teach more, but don't feel secure enough about earning a sufficient income, because of the messages that keep coming back again and again: "Well, of course you can't make a living as a piano teacher," or "Of course it's just retired grannies supplementing their income with piano teaching" (or music teaching, whatever instrument you teach). This belief is part of what keeps all those teachers stuck, and it doesn't need to be this way at all. But we need to talk about it.
A qualification won't fix the mindset
Having a qualification won't fix this mindset. It won't suddenly make you feel like a professional music teacher and value your time and what you offer your students. I had a good degree from a good university; I went to Imperial. It wasn't a music degree, but I'd gone down this, in inverted commas, "proper" career path, and I still saw piano teaching as a side job. Having a degree didn't make me feel professional. It was never the missing piece.
As I've said before, I've spoken with plenty of piano teachers who have music degrees, diplomas and performance experience, and they still undercharge. In fact, many with music degrees say, "I'm not too sure how much having a music degree helps me in my day-to-day teaching." Because you learn from experience, from engaging with other teachers and picking up tips and tricks along the way, and from learning who you are as a teacher. That takes time, so it isn't about what's on your CV.
I've spoken about the Piano Teachers' Course a couple of times. I took the CertPTC qualification and got a merit, which I was very proud of, back in 2024. The mindset shift was already happening for me, but doing the course accelerated it. I felt so much more professional, and much better equipped to teach the way I wanted to.
So, absolutely, it's great having the letters after my name. I added them to my email signature as soon as my certificate came through, and they do add a sense of security. But the real value of that qualification was everything I learned about how to teach and how to run my business. I'll put a link to the Piano Teachers' Course in the show notes. They've expanded the courses they offer since I did it. I did the CertPTC, but there's now a foundation course for new teachers, an accelerated ARSM course and many other courses. It's absolutely fantastic, because it's geared around exactly what you need to learn as a piano teacher, and it helps you learn about yourself as a teacher. It's a very valuable form of continuing professional development, so the link will be in the show notes.
Even if you don't have any letters after your name, your professional credibility comes from how you run your studio, how you treat your students, and your commitment to learning, not just for your own skills, but about teaching, new methods and approaches. I'm going to link Episode 10, "You Are A Professional Music Teacher", and Episode 11, "What Makes A Good Music Teacher?", in the show notes. They're definitely worth listening to, to get you into the right frame of mind and understand what you bring as a music teacher, and why you're a professional.
Part 4: Earning a living from teaching, and what to do next
From 70 school students to 21 private students
I've already said that I'm a professional piano teacher, earning a respectable living from full-time piano teaching. It's a valid occupation.
I received a voice message from a piano teacher friend the other week, thanking me because she'd listened to every episode of the podcast and it had given her the confidence to make some big changes. She'd been teaching 70 students. (I shrink away at the thought of 70 students; I'd be a puddle on the floor.) She was teaching 70 students in schools, and she was completely burnt out, which I can totally understand. She recently switched to private teaching and now has 21 students, and her income has only dropped by a couple of hundred pounds a month. She's still building up more private students, so that will likely even out very soon. But the change in her quality of life has been enormous.
So she's proof that you can make this switch. You don't have to take on every single student, and you don't have to work in schools if you don't want to.
Why teachers go into schools
Lots of piano teachers and music teachers go straight into schools, because that's an automatic source of students, of course. I'm speaking with no experience of my own, because I've never worked in schools. I can see the benefits, but I've heard lots of stories from teachers who work in schools and have had quite negative experiences: limits on how they can set up and run their lessons, restrictions imposed by the school itself, additional fees charged to teachers for using rooms, all sorts of things like that.
Lots of teachers feel they have to go into schools to get students, because they don't believe they can attract students to their own private teaching studio, and that goes hand in hand with this mindset. But you don't need to teach 70 students a week just to make ends meet. You can charge what you're worth.
The other thing about teaching in schools is that I've heard a lot of feedback from teachers where the school charges a fee, takes a cut, and the teacher gets peanuts, which isn't something you can support yourself on. That's a real shame, because we need more music in schools, but music teachers deserve to be paid properly.
So you don't have to take on 70 students, work seven days a week or work weekends. In fact, that reminds me of another episode I've done, "I Don't Work Late and I Don't Work Weekends", which I'll link in the show notes as well.
The teacher doing a full-time job plus 30 students
I also saw a post last week from a teacher (get this) with a full-time nine to five job, who was also teaching 30 private students in a rented studio, and was completely burnt out. They wanted to move to teaching from home, but didn't really know how to make that transition, and also needed to build in a bit of a break while making the change. This is exactly the kind of teacher I'm here to support.
I don't understand how they've managed to do a full-time job and 30 students. What did I have, five? Maybe I got up to six or seven when I was teaching part-time alongside my full-time job. But that was plenty; that was enough.
The whole package
What makes it possible to earn a respectable living as a music teacher is a combination of things: having the right studio policies and upholding them, being professional, being kind and warm, and attracting your ideal students. It's the whole package that builds a studio that supports you without burning you out.
This is my whole reason for being. It's why I do all of this, and why the podcast exists. I've made the switch to being a piano teacher who runs her own studio, and it's succeeding. I'm doing the thing I love without having to sacrifice an income to do it. You can have it all. You just need all the pieces of the puzzle to line up, and that's what's covered across all these episodes.
If you're not already aware, I offer one-to-one Focus Sessions, an online chat for teachers who want help planning this kind of shift. That will be in the show notes if you're interested and want to find out more.
"I don't need the money, so why shouldn't I be flexible?"
This is probably my favourite section of every podcast episode, where I address the objections. These are drawn from my own experience and conversations with other teachers; they're real objections.
Here's the first one: "I don't need the money, so why shouldn't I be flexible?" Absolutely, how you run your studio is your own choice. But the flexibility doesn't just stay with you. Families carry those expectations to the next teacher, who may rely on teaching for their living. And even if you don't need the money, you deserve to be paid properly for your time and expertise.
"Charging less is kinder to families"
Objection number two: "Charging less is kinder to families." I disagree. Kindness shows up in how you teach and how you treat people, not in undercharging. It's a bit like buying gifts to make friends. You don't make friends by buying them things. Well, some people do, but those aren't real friends. You make friends by being you and making connections. In the same way, you can be kind to your students and families through how you teach and how you treat them as people. Low rates and endless flexibility tell families that music lessons are optional extras, which makes things harder for every single teacher.
"GCSEs matter more than music lessons"
Number three: "The parents are right. GCSEs matter more than piano," or more than music lessons. Yes, exams matter, and it's the family's decision. But music doesn't need to be the first thing to go. Many students manage to study for exams and continue music lessons, just as I did, and as many of my colleagues have when this topic has come up in debates. So many of us say, "What? We carried on with lessons. It wasn't a big deal. Why is it such a big deal these days?" Piano lessons, or whatever instrument you teach, can be a welcome break from revision, and from the obligation I experienced to revise in every waking hour of the day, rather than one more pressure.
"I can't call myself a professional without a music degree"
Objection number four: "I can't call myself a professional without a music degree." I had a degree and still didn't see teaching as a real job. Admittedly, it wasn't a music degree, but the qualification isn't what creates that feeling. Your professional credibility comes from how you run your studio and how you care for your students. Further training, specific training like the CertPTC from the Piano Teachers' Course, is valuable for what you learn, not for the letters it gives you, and I say that wholeheartedly.
"You can't make a proper living from teaching piano"
Objection number five: "You can't make a proper living from teaching piano." I completely disagree. My friend I mentioned a minute ago moved from 70 school students to 21 private students, with only a tiny drop in income and a far better quality of life. It takes the right policies, the right rates and the right students, but it absolutely is possible.
To sum up
The belief that teaching isn't a real job is something we absorb from our environment and the way people talk about it. It's not a conclusion we come to after doing it. It's a real job; we all know that. This belief is costly to us as individual music teachers, and to the music teaching profession as a whole. If we keep having to fight against the idea that what we do isn't a real job, it's always going to feel difficult. So we need to do what we can to change that myth, because it really is a myth. It's a real job. It deserves to be paid for, and it provides real value and impact in people's lives.
A qualification won't fix this belief on its own. It can help a little, but the shift in your mindset is what makes you believe you're a professional music teacher. And we've come to the conclusion, at the end of this episode, that making a living from music teaching is absolutely possible.
One thing to try this week
Something I'd like you to try this week is to notice where you describe your teaching as "just" something, or as a side thing, whether in conversation, on your website, or even just in your own head: "Oh, I'm just a piano teacher." "Oh, I just teach lessons on the side." "I just teach at the weekend."
Then rewrite how you introduce what you do. The most obvious example is the one I've already given today. You go from "Oh, I teach piano lessons" (or harp lessons, or violin lessons), "I teach on the side," "I teach at weekends," "I just teach a few students," to "I am a piano teacher." It's as simple as that.
Once you've written it down, say it out loud. If you're embarrassed and anyone's around, wait until they're not, or go to your room and say it to yourself: "I am a violin teacher." "I am a piano teacher." Because your sense of identity comes from knowing you're a professional music teacher, and this helps you make that shift.
To teachers who teach alongside another income, please hear me: you deserve to be paid properly too. Even if you don't need the money, your choices matter to our entire profession of music teachers. So please charge what you're worth.
I hope you've enjoyed today's episode, and that it's given you some food for thought. If you know any teacher friends who really want to make the leap to full-time teaching, but aren't sure whether it's viable, or don't have the confidence or self-belief that they can make it work, do them a favour and share this episode with them. It absolutely is a viable profession, and more of us need to believe in it. The more of us who talk about these issues, the more we can squash the myths that persist around music teaching.
Thank you so much for listening today. I value your support enormously, and it fills my heart with joy every time I get messages from music teachers who've listened to this episode or that one and told me how much it's helped them. I absolutely love getting those messages. If you've enjoyed this episode, I'd be so grateful if you could leave me a review, or even just a rating, on whichever podcast platform you listen on. I look forward to seeing you in the next episode. Bye.